46 Comments
User's avatar
Michelle Wilson's avatar

My favorite is Kinsey Milhone from the ABC series by Sue Grafton. I love a mystery before computers. I think she was an original badass!

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

Congrats! You won. Can you please email me (whattoreadif@substack.com) your address?

Thanks!

Expand full comment
DJ Weiss's avatar

My favorites are Maisie Dobbs and Armand Ganache

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

Love both of these!

Expand full comment
Anya's avatar

I think after Nancy Drew, my entry into detective books of any kind were the Stephanie Plum books by Janet Evanovich. She's a bounty hunter but more often than not felt like a detective from my perspective. I'm really excited to read 'Scorched Grace' since I have read any detective books in a while.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

Congrats! You won. Can you please email me (whattoreadif@substack.com) your address?

Thanks!

Expand full comment
Al's avatar

This is basic but I started with Miss Marple and I am also an avid knitter who is deeply nosy and there's a reason she has stuck around.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

So when I first read Miss Marple, I couldn't get into her. Now in my 30s, I love her.

Expand full comment
Tracey Costanzo's avatar

I like Louise Penny's Detective Gamache. And I can't wait to read Scorched Grace because it reminds me of my friend I lost to cancer. She was a queer nun and a remarkable lady.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

She sounds remarkable!

Expand full comment
Sarah Miller's avatar

My favorite fictional detective -- and the reason I am such a mystery reader to this day -- is Laura Lippman's Tess Monaghan. I love her so damn much.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

I read Baltimore Blues in the beginning of March 2020. It's not an exaggeration to say Laura Lippman helped me survive those first few crazy weeks.

Expand full comment
Sarah Miller's avatar

Yes!

Expand full comment
Colleen's avatar

A detective I love is Vera Stanhope.

Expand full comment
Neal Thompson's avatar

Great interview! Such a fun book.

Expand full comment
Trevor Lovell's avatar

I’m a fan of Chesterton’s Father Brown. He’s an unexpected character too, as someone who is innocent but not simple or naive. The stories are always a good laugh. Scorched Grace sounds awesome.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

I was struck by how much thinking Margot has done about spiritual mysteries. Interested to see what you think of Scorched Grace!

Expand full comment
Jennifer Kathleen Gibbons's avatar

Three way tie between Nancy Drew, Maisie Dobbs, and Kinsey Milhone.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

Congrats! You won. Can you please email me (whattoreadif@substack.com) your address?

Thanks!

Expand full comment
Jennifer Kathleen Gibbons's avatar

Wow thanks! I'll send you mailing address...

Expand full comment
Stephanie Li's avatar

My favorite fictional detective is Enola Holmes.

Expand full comment
JenniferS's avatar

I love the Clare Fergusson series (as well as Armand gamache and Maisie dobbs). Clare is so flawed and faithful and trying to do good.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

Three of my faves. I love love love Clare. Meeting Julia Spencer Fleming was one of the highlights of my 2022.

Expand full comment
Anne's avatar

My favorite fictional detective is Harbinder Kaur.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

Congrats! You won. Can you please email me (whattoreadif@substack.com) your address?

Thanks!

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

I've read Post Script Murders. I need to read more of them.

Expand full comment
Jim Ruland's avatar

I've read Scorched Grace and it's great!

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

It feels very Jim to me.

Expand full comment
Jim Ruland's avatar

Very!

Expand full comment
Nancy Reddy's avatar

This book sounds great, and what a cover! I'm a fan (always) of Armand Gamache, but something about this interview is reminding me of Laura Lippman's Tess Monaghan books, too.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth's avatar

There is definitely some Tess Monaghan DNA in Sister Holiday.

Expand full comment
Judie McCourt's avatar

My favourite detectives are Rebus, VI Warshawski, Miss Marple

Expand full comment
Michelle Wilson's avatar

Oooh! I forgot about Vic!

Expand full comment